Questions asked by students: ES&L

Questions asked by students thinking of enrolling in ES&L

Do I have to be a Trinity student to take ES&L?

No. You can be a student at any of the other colleges on the St. George campus and still take the program.

What can I do with a major program in ES&L?

Since 1988, ES&L has served as a significant part of an undergraduate degree in preparation for further studies or careers in such fields as the law, public policy, philosophy, political science, and criminology. 

ES&L allows undergraduates to explore issues in ethics, society, and law, and to do so by means of an explicitly interdisciplinary approach in a small and intimate program with excellent colleagues. We are based at Trinity College in the University of Toronto.

Many of the issues at the intersection of ethics, society, and law that we study are crucial contemporary issues. Students are required to cover core areas in each stream, but are also allowed to select their own areas of focus from many optional courses.

Each year, a number of students choose ES&L in order to explore the study of the law and see if they are genuinely interested in law school as a post-graduate option.

Majors commonly doubled with ES&L include Political Science, Philosophy, and Criminology.

So ES&L is not a "pre-law" program?

Right, ES&L is not designed for "pre-law" students in particular. However, many of the students in ES&L do go on to law schools.

What if my first request to enroll in the program is unsuccessful?

In recent years, ES&L has had 250-275 requests in the first round each spring, and about 100 more requests in the second round each summer. There are only about 70 new spots available in the program each year. Thus the program's cut-off in the required courses does float up into the B+ range.

Achieving the threshold average in the relevant courses does not ensure invitation to the program, as is stated in the ES&L entry in the Faculty of Arts and Science Calendar.

Students who are not successful in their first request are certainly welcome to apply in subsequent rounds or years, and in the interim to take courses (that are not restricted to ES&L students) that count in the program. Such students may also want to consider requesting minors in Philosophy or Political Science, for example, to get priority in (and to take) POL and PHL courses that count in the program.

The program is becoming increasingly popular and competitive. Each interested student should assess carefully the likelihood of achieving a competitive average in the courses required for entry; if there are concerns about achieving the average, a "plan B" would be a good idea.

The cut-offs cannot be predicted with certainty. They depend on the number and quality of requests in each round.

The online FAS Calendar (p. 590) stipulates the relevant base requirements:

The Ethics, Society, and Law Major is a Type 2 limited enrolment program. Enrolment is limited to students with an overall average of 73% or higher in 3 FCEs (at the end of first year) selected from courses that are categorized as BR=2 and/or BR=3. For students applying at the end of second year, a minimal overall average of 73% is required in 3 FCEs, as follows: (a) PHL271H1, (b) 2.5 FCEs from other courses that count towards the program including at least 0.5 FCE from: POL200Y1, PHL265H1, PHL275H1, ETH201H1, ETH210H1, ETH220H1, and ETH230H1. In either case, achieving the threshold mark does not necessarily guarantee admission to the program in any given year. Applications beyond second year will be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

If I have already taken some ES&L courses before enrolling in the program, can I count them as program credits?

Yes. For example, if you take PHL 273H (Environmental Ethics) before enrolling in the program, you can count it as a program credit.

If I enrol in ES&L and in another major program or in two additional minor programs, and if I take a course that can be used to satisfy a requirement in two of these programs, can I count the course for credit in both programs or in only one?

You may use the course to satisfy requirements in both programs provided that your programs (two majors or one major and two minors) include at least twelve different courses (FCEs). Please consult the Degree Requirements section of the Faculty of Arts and Science Calendar and your College Registrar for further information on double-counting courses.

What about prerequisites for courses in ES&L?

Many upper-year courses in the program have prerequisites determined by their home departments or colleges, and many of these prerequisites are not ES&L courses. Thus students need to plan ahead and make sure their program of study fulfills the prerequisite requirements for the courses they wish to take in upper years.

Although the ES&L program does not have any 100-level requirements, there are upper-year courses in the program that have 100-level prerequisites. You need to make yourself aware of these prerequisites and plan accordingly.

 

Questions asked by students enrolled in the program

Is there anything special I need to know about being in a program in which most of the courses are listed from a number of other departments and colleges?

Yes.

First, the chief benefits of being in such a program are flexibility and inter-disciplinarity. The options available to you have been drawn from many departments and colleges in the Faculty of Arts & Science.

Second, this means that many of the courses do not give priority to ES&L students. Thus you need to plan ahead carefully, and enrol in courses as soon as your enrolment period is open. It would also be advisable to have alternative selections in mind when enrolling. Students may want to consider requesting minors in Philosophy or Political Science, for example, temporarily to get priority in (and to take) POL and PHL courses that count in the program.

Third, many upper-year courses in the program have prerequisites determined by their home departments or programs, and many of those prerequisites are not ES&L courses; thus you need to plan ahead and make sure your program of study fulfills the prerequisite requirements for the courses you wish to take in upper years.

Where can I find a list of courses available in ES&L?

Please see the lists of courses, starting at: ES&L at Trinity: Requirements and Courses.  The lists, divided into required courses and streams A, B, C, and D. Official course lists and descriptions can be found in the FAS Calendar.

If you notice a change in the status of a course offering that should be recorded on our web pages, please inform the ES&L Director

May I substitute a different course for one of the courses in the program?

With the permission of the Program Director, you may substitute courses not listed in the program for a maximum of two of the program's optional courses (FCEs).

There are some 80 optional courses listed in ES&L; unless you have a relevant timetable conflict or some other special circumstance making it necessary that you look for a substitute, we do not normally grant substitution credits.

If such circumstances are the case, please send the Director (1) a brief email note clearly explaining the necessity for the substitution credit, as well as the following information: (2a) the full calendar course description (with web address), (2b) the departmental description for the course (if any, and web address), and (2c) the course website and description for the course (if any). Potential substitution credits should have official calendar descriptions that indicate content directly relevant to the study of ethics, society or law. The Director's decision will be based largely on whether or not, in his or her judgment, the course(s) would be suitable for inclusion in the program.

If I find a course (not listed in ES&L) that I think would be a suitable course for the program, what can I do?

You should tell the ES&L director. 

What if I do not have a prerequisite for an ES&L course I want to take?

This would normally mean you would not be eligible to take the course. If, however, you think you have equivalent preparation, you should speak with the instructor.

What role does TRN 303H1 (Ethics and Society) play in the ES&L program?

TRN 303H1 Ethics and Society, like PHL271H1 (Law and Morality) and TRN412H1 (Seminar in Ethics, Society, and Law), is one of ES&L's core required courses. In addition to its focus on the intersection of ethics and society, TRN 303H1 includes two other important elements:

--Students are asked to complete essay assignments that give them practice writing a research paper of the sort they will be required to complete in TRN412H1. This measure enables compliance with the protocol in the Degree Objectives Guidelines that “preparatory experiences for [a fourth-year integrative inquiry-based activity] should occur at earlier stages in the program.”

--Students are asked to complete a component on interpreting and evaluating quantitative data in the context of ethical reasoning about social issues. This component of the course provides an introductory treatment of a selection of specific topics such as polling, sampling, graphs, correlations and causal claims. The course includes an assignment requiring the interpretation, evaluation, and use of quantitative data in an ethical examination of (one or more aspects of) a selected social issue.

What role does TRN 407Y (Community Research Partnerships in Ethics) play in the ES&L program?

Typically in mid-July the 2-8 senior ES&L majors with the highest cGPAs are invited to join the Community Research Partnerships in Ethics course. The course is challenging and the number of projects is limited. It is unlikely the cut-off would go below a cGPA of about 3.50 in any given year. The course is administered either by the director of the Ethics, Society, and Law program, or a CRPE Project Coordinator, and is supported by the Centre for Ethics. Each student project is supervised by a University of Toronto faculty member.

CRPE Student Testimonial: I was involved with the CRPE program during the 2006-2007 academic year with Professor Joseph Heath as my supervisor. The community partner I worked with was the Canada Africa Partnership on AIDS (CAP/AIDS). My research focused on the difference between small, medium, and large-sized NGOs, and on value added in the work that CAP/AIDS does in order to inform its strategic planning. The program allowed me to gain hands-on experience and undertake a project that not only interested me, but also benefited a community organization. It enabled me to apply and develop my research skills and academic knowledge while also illuminating how ethics can be applied to tackle real-world problems in real-world settings. The most enjoyable part of my project was engaging with the various stakeholders, such as not-for-profit groups, and learning about how they operated. Being able to put together a final academic paper and present it at the CRPE conference was a highly enriching experience and all-in-all I would endorse the CRPE program and definitely recommend it to others.  --Alex Lim 

What role does TRN 412H (Capstone Seminar) play in the ES&L program?

Its role is to integrate the program by examining selected topics and readings related to the themes of ethics, society, and law in the format of a senior seminar. The course is restricted to students in their final year of registration in the program.  

TRN 412H1 requires a major research paper in which students conduct an inquiry into a selected social issue with ethical and legal aspects.  The inquiry is expected to be integrative in at least two ways: it must integrate material covered in the seminar with the student’s research on the chosen topic, and it must integrate material from each of the program’s general thematic categories (“ethics,” “society,” and “law”).

The inquiry is expected to involve “the (independent) framing and investigation of nontrivial questions,” and it is desirable (but not necessary) to require group activity allowing students “to interact with one another in a way that facilitates discussion of their investigations” (Degree Objectives Guidelines, p. 9). (A group-activity approach of this nature was adopted in 2010-11 by the instructor of a section of TRN412H1. He required the students to post one-page abstracts of their research papers on the Blackboard website for the course so as to share their research results with one another.) 

What role does TRN 425Y (Law Workshops) play in the ES&L program?

Typically in mid-July the 12-15 senior ES&L majors with the highest cGPAs are invited to join the Law Workshops course. The course is challenging and seating is limited. It is unlikely the cut-off would go below a cGPA of about 3.50 in any given year. Students attend workshops in the Faculty of Law, meet with an instructor for related instruction and discussion, and complete related assignments.